Organisations and sources Β· Israeli NGO of military veterans collecting soldiers' testimonies

Breaking the Silence (Shovrim Shtika)

What it is

'Founded in March 2004 by a group of soldiers who served in Hebron', in its own words.

'an organization of veteran soldiers who have served in the Israeli military since the start of the Second Intifada'. Its About page lists its board, staff and a testimony-collection and research department.

Who funds it

By its own transparency page: 'Over 50% of our funding last year came from foreign governmental entities.' It names donors 'as of 2025', among them the EU Delegation to Israel, the Norwegian and Swiss foreign ministries, Spain's AECID, the Government of Canada, the New Israel Fund, the Rockefeller Brothers Fund and several church aid agencies.

What it wants

To 'expose the public to the reality of everyday life in the Occupied Territories' and 'stimulate public debate about the price paid' when 'young soldiers face a civilian population on a daily basis'. It states: 'Our work aims to bring an end to the occupation.'

Why it makes its arguments

Originator: it makes these arguments as part of its own programme.

Stated aim, in its own words: 'Our work aims to bring an end to the occupation.' (Breaking the Silence, 'The Organization' (About page))

Is there reason to doubt it?

  • Does it say what it is? Yes: a veterans' organisation that collects testimonies, states its aim of ending the occupation, and publishes its donors and the share of funding from foreign governments. (Breaking the Silence, 'Transparency' page)
  • What do its critics say, and on what evidence? NGO Monitor calls its testimonies 'anonymous and unverifiable hearsay' and stresses foreign-government funding (NIS 51.3 million, 2012–2024, from Registrar filings). The same page reports that the High Court dismissed a 2020 petition to have it investigated. The funding share is also stated by the group itself (over 50%). (NGO Monitor, 'Breaking the Silence (Shovrim Shtika)' profile page)

Only what is documented: stated aims in the actor's own words, and sourced tests of them. 'No evidence found' is a finding too. See the argument that isn't meant to win.

Its record

  • December 2015: the right-wing group Im Tirtzu's video called four named human-rights workers 'moles', one of them from Breaking the Silence; the same day the education minister, Naftali Bennett, banned it from public-school programmes (JTA). Cited on freedom-to-dissent and purity-loop.
  • Critics' account (NGO Monitor, which analyses NGOs' funding and methods; see its org page): it calls the testimonies behind 'war crimes' charges 'anonymous and unverifiable hearsay', and says the group's advocacy focuses on 'international audiences'. It quotes co-founder Yehuda Shaul: 'Sometimes, when you want to deliver messages to the inside, you must go outside'; and Avner Gvaryahu: 'our role is to publicize testimonies. If someone in Israel or abroad sees fit to use our materials, they are welcome to do so.' From Registrar filings it totals 'NIS 51,261,739 from foreign governmental bodies in 2012-2024'.
  • Legal challenges, as NGO Monitor reports them: in January 2021 two soldiers sued the group and a former crewmate for defamation, alleging 'false testimony' (outcome not stated there ⚠); in March 2020 Ad Kan petitioned the High Court to order an investigation into it for collecting 'sensitive military intelligence', and 'In October 2020, the High Court of Justice dismissed the case.'
  • Independent assessments of how accurate its testimonies are remain unsourced here ⚠.

Citation cluster

Israeli human-rights and anti-occupation NGOs (with B'Tselem, Yesh Din, HaMoked).

How to read a claim sourced from here

Read its testimonies as first-hand soldiers' accounts selected by an organisation whose stated aim is 'to bring an end to the occupation'. Each testimony's specifics (unit, place, date) are what can be checked. It says its testimonies portray a 'much grimmer' picture than the official description of abuses as 'extreme' and 'unique' cases, and that is its claim to test, case by case. Its foreign-government funding is stated by the organisation itself.

Where it comes up

Sources

  • Breaking the Silence, 'The Organization' (About page) βœ“
    What was readRead 2026-09-29: 'founded in March 2004 by a group of soldiers who served in Hebron'; 'Our work aims to bring an end to the occupation'.
  • Breaking the Silence, 'Transparency' page βœ“
    What was readRead 2026-09-29: 'Over 50% of our funding last year came from foreign governmental entities', with named donors as of 2025.
  • JTA, 'Im Tirtzu calls Israeli human rights activists "moles"' (16 December 2015) βœ“
    What was readRead (2026-09-28). Video 'Foreign Agents revealed', posted on founder Ronen Shoval's Facebook page, naming Yishai Menuhin (PCATI), Avner Gvaryahu (Breaking the Silence), Sigi Ben Ari (HaMoked) and Hagai El-Ad (B'Tselem): 'Hagai, Yishai, Avner and Sigi – are Israelis like us. And they are moles. They are members of the New Israel Fund organizations. And they act against the State of Israel and IDF soldiers.' HaMoked asked the attorney general to investigate Im Tirtzu for incitement to murder; J Street: it has 'crossed every conceivable line of decency'. Same day: Bennett banned Breaking the Silence from public-school programmes.
  • NGO Monitor, 'Breaking the Silence (Shovrim Shtika)' profile page βœ“
    What was readRead 2026-09-29 (a critic): testimonies as 'anonymous and unverifiable hearsay'; a focus on 'international audiences'; NIS 51,261,739 from foreign governmental bodies 2012–2024 (Registrar filings). The same page reports the 2021 soldiers' defamation suit (no outcome given) and Ad Kan's 2020 petition, which 'the High Court of Justice dismissed'.