Organisations and sources Β· Israeli political marketing firm; ran a fake-account network removed by Meta in 2024
STOIC (Tel Aviv)
What it is
Described by Meta as 'a political marketing and business intelligence firm based in Tel Aviv, Israel'. Founding details not read here β .
A commercial firm. Its own site and statements have not been read here.
Who funds it
Commercial clients. Who paid for the 2023β24 network is disputed (see below).
What it wants
No public statement of aim has been found. What it did is documented by Meta's takedown report.
Why it makes its arguments
Amplifier: it spreads arguments that others originated.
Stated aim, in its own words: No public statement of aim found. Meta: 'a political marketing and business intelligence firm'. Its network's content was 'supportive commentary about Israel'. (Meta Q1 2024 report)
Is there reason to doubt it?
- Who commissioned it? Meta's report does not name a client. The New York Times, citing four anonymous ministry officials and documents, named Israel's Diaspora Affairs Ministry ($2 million). The ministry denied any connection. The claim is sourced but disputed. (Meta (2024); JNS on the NYT report and the ministry's denial (5 June 2024))
- Did it work? Meta: the network had about 500 Page followers and some 2,000 Instagram followers, and its comments were 'often met with critical responses from authentic users calling them propaganda'. (Meta Q1 2024 report)
Its arguments, measured against its stated aim
- That's hasbara β Israel pays people to post this. β fits the stated aim. The 'hasbara' charge (that pro-Israel voices online are paid or fake) has a documented case here. The entry's point also stands: a network of a few hundred fake accounts cannot account for the people who hold pro-Israel views, and the label answers who said something, not whether it is true. (Meta Q1 2024 report)
Only what is documented: stated aims in the actor's own words, and sourced tests of them. 'No evidence found' is a finding too. See the argument that isn't meant to win.
Its record
- Meta's report for the first quarter of 2024 describes a network of 510 Facebook accounts, 11 Pages, one Group and 32 Instagram accounts linked to it, targeting the US and Canada with 'supportive commentary about Israel' and criticism of Muslims and UNRWA. The comments were 'often met with critical responses from authentic users calling them propaganda', and some were 'likely generated using artificial intelligence'. Meta banned it from its platforms.
- The New York Times reported in June 2024, citing four anonymous current and former officials of Israel's Diaspora Affairs Ministry and documents, that the ministry allocated $2 million for the campaign and hired the firm. The ministry called it a 'false publication' and said: 'The Ministry of Diaspora Affairs and Combating Antisemitism does not engage in disinformation campaigns' (both as reported by JNS).
Citation cluster
An amplifier with no side of its own in the argument: a firm paid to spread one side's messages through fake personas. It is the same kind of operation as the Iran-based network in Meta's report, which posed as Israelis (see 'The argument that isn't meant to win').
How to read a claim sourced from here
When a comment or account praises or attacks either side, check whether it is a real person. Takedown reports by the platforms are the best public record of such networks.
Where it comes up
Sources
- Meta, 'Quarterly Adversarial Threat Report, Q1 2024' β
What was read
Read (2026-09-28). 'found links to STOIC, a political marketing and business intelligence firm based in Tel Aviv, Israel. It is now banned from our platform'; 510 Facebook accounts, 11 Pages, one Group, 32 Instagram accounts; about 500 Page followers, ~2,000 Instagram followers; targeted the US and Canada; commented on pages of media and 'political and public figures, including US lawmakers'; 'supportive commentary about Israel' (incl. its military actions, per the report's summary table); criticism of Muslims and UNRWA; comments 'often met with critical responses from authentic users calling them propaganda'; some comments 'likely generated using artificial intelligence'. The report does not name who commissioned the operation. Iran-based network: 22 Facebook accounts, eight Pages, eight Groups, 23 Instagram accounts; 'originated in Iran and targeted Israel'; 'fictitious personas posing as Israelis'; 'supportive commentary about Israel'; support for Itamar Ben-Gvir while criticising Netanyahu; accounts that 'posed as young liberal Israeli women and posted about anti-government protests'. Re-read 2026-10-12: the comments 'included links to the operation's websites and were often met with critical responses from authentic users calling them propaganda'. - JNS, 'J'lem pans βNYTβ story accusing it of covert campaign to influence Congress' (5 June 2024) β
What was read
Read 2026-09-28 (5 June 2024): reports the New York Times' account (four anonymous ministry officials and documents; the Diaspora Affairs Ministry; $2 million) and the ministry's denial: it 'does not engage in disinformation campaigns'.